How I studied Political Science and International Relations for Civil Service Exams
I am not trying to share a foolproof fit-for-all strategy to crack PSIR here because there cannot be any such strategy. Instead,I will share the sources I studied for each and every topic here. I must confess that I never did writing practice, I did not attend any mock tests and I did not take notes except for loose sheets like "List of International Organisations","Names of thinkers and their famous books" and other such school-level stuff. But what I had as my strength was a diverse reading habit which ranged from newspapers to magazines to works of non-fiction by Granville Austin,Ashutosh Varshney,David Malone et al. A topic-wise analysis of syllabus follows :
Paper I
Part 1
This section can be divided into four parts : Political Theory, Indian Political Thought,Western Political Thought and Political Ideologies.
For Political Theory, my basic text was Andrew Heywood's "Political Theory" which helped me attain conceptual clarity in all fundamental topics like Equality,Rights,Power,Liberty and Democracy. Once Heywood is done, we can move on to O.P.Gauba.I must confess that I never completed even half of this book because of it's convoluted style of writing. (In engineering,local authors helped me clear exams whereas in PSIR, foreign authors were more lucid).But O.P.Gauba has it's utility because it fills the gaps in Andrew Heywood and it is written keeping in mind an Indian syllabus. So numbers 1 to 7 (refer syllabus)in Part 1 of Paper I can be mastered by thorough reading of Heywood followed by selective reading of Gauba.
For Political Ideologies, Political Ideologies by Andrew Heywood is a gift from Heaven. Look no further. Gandhism alone can be covered in Indian Political Thought.
For Western Political Thought , the book by Brian Nelson is very good. This book covers some ideologies too. Some quotes and questions from Paper 1 related to Western thinkers in 2013 were directly from this book only. Gramsci and Hannah Arendt are missing in this book.
I covered Gramsci and Hannah Arendt in O.P.Gauba's "Political Theory" and also through some online reading.
For Indian Political Thought , V.R.Mehta's book is a good source to study even if the language is not easy to master. Ambedkar and Syed Ahmed Khan are missing in this book which can be covered in IGNOU PDFs.I read the original texts of "Annihilation of caste" and "Hind Swaraj".
Part II
Indian Government and Politics:
I considered this entire section as an organic whole and the basic texts for it are B.L.Fadia, Laxmikanth, Ramachandra Guha and Bipan Chandra. But ultimately,this is a current affairs oriented section and we win or lose within the pages of a good newspaper.
Answers in these sections must have contemporary examples and can quote good authors. For example, for a question on "Marginalisation of Left Ideology in India" in 2014's paper, I quoted Ramachandra Guha's points from a piece for Caravan Magazine in June,2011. So, every weekend, few hours can be spent to browse websites of Indian Express, Outlook and India Today etc. There is a tendency to see Times of India as a frivolous page- 3 paper but it features columns of great writers like Sunil Khilnani and Gurcharan Das on a regular basis.
I would suggest columns of Ashutosh Varshney,Ramachandra Guha and Pratap Bhanu Mehta as mandatory reading for this section.
Paper II
Part I
Comparative Political Analysis and International Politics:
This can be divided into two sections : Comparative Politics and International Relations.
Comparative Politics was the only portion in PSIR's syllabus which never kindled my interest enough to do extensive reading. All I read for this section were IGNOU PDFs.
For International Relations,a wonderful introductory text is Globalisation of World Politics. This book is an absolute delight with great illustrations,brilliant design and most importantly,quality content. Any gaps in this book can be filled by selective reading of V.K.Malhotra's "International Relations".
Again,answers for this section can be written with references to recent examples. For example,an answer on National Security can mention Syrian crisis as an example.BBC website provides great summaries of all current international crises (Sample: See this)."Frontline" is a good Indian magazine to cover international events if one discounts it's blinkered worldview.
Part II
For Indian foreign Policy, a topnotch introductory text is David Malone's book. Gaps in this book can be filled by reading Shashi Tharoor OR Rajiv Sikri selectively.
But as anyone who saw/wrote 2014's paper would know, even without reading any book, this section can be mastered if we follow The Hindu and good columnists regularly. Some expert foreign policy commentators include : C.Rajamohan, Brahma Challaney ,Suhasini Haidar and Srinath Raghavan. (For a question on India-Russia relations, I almost reproduced Srinath Raghavan's viewpoints written in the pages of The Hindu five days before the exam.) I never read a single issue of World Focus (even though I bought so many issues only for them to rest in the attic) and relied more on these commentators I have mentioned.
Thus, PSIR can be mastered by a diverse reading habit along with very good writing. Why I insist on Andrew Heywood first (and not Gauba) and Srinath Raghavan (and not World Focus) is because when we read such lucidly written prose regularly, our writing will also gain finesse with time. So,our answers for PSIR should
i) introduce the statement in the question , analyse the viewpoints associated with it and conclude it . It is important to ensure our answers have a closure to it. We must not write like students appearing for B.A Pol. Sci exam.Rather,we must write like a bureaucrat submitting a report to a higher official.
ii) Our answers should have contemporary examples and touches.For example,a question on women panchayats should mention examples of successful and popular woman sarpanches.
iii) We can quote authors and columnists in answers. It adds to the intellectual heft of our viewpoints.
iv) Above all, reading more means writing better.
The above is not exactly a strategy but a recounting of what I did to score 138+140 in PSIR this year. All the best to all aspirants who are taking up this wonderful optional wherein we are mesmerised by Gandhi's idealism, stunned by Ambedkar's radicalism,transfixed by Aristotle's pragmatism,intrigued by Marx's,er,Marxism and exasperated by Modi's foreign policy tourism. ("Oh ,which country ? Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz wat ? Ok google "India- Kazakhstan relations"?)
Important Note : If you feel that the books mentioned fall short in a particular topic/dimension, do supplement it with IGNOU materials.
Paper I
Part 1
This section can be divided into four parts : Political Theory, Indian Political Thought,Western Political Thought and Political Ideologies.
For Political Theory, my basic text was Andrew Heywood's "Political Theory" which helped me attain conceptual clarity in all fundamental topics like Equality,Rights,Power,Liberty and Democracy. Once Heywood is done, we can move on to O.P.Gauba.I must confess that I never completed even half of this book because of it's convoluted style of writing. (In engineering,local authors helped me clear exams whereas in PSIR, foreign authors were more lucid).But O.P.Gauba has it's utility because it fills the gaps in Andrew Heywood and it is written keeping in mind an Indian syllabus. So numbers 1 to 7 (refer syllabus)in Part 1 of Paper I can be mastered by thorough reading of Heywood followed by selective reading of Gauba.
For Political Ideologies, Political Ideologies by Andrew Heywood is a gift from Heaven. Look no further. Gandhism alone can be covered in Indian Political Thought.
For Western Political Thought , the book by Brian Nelson is very good. This book covers some ideologies too. Some quotes and questions from Paper 1 related to Western thinkers in 2013 were directly from this book only. Gramsci and Hannah Arendt are missing in this book.
I covered Gramsci and Hannah Arendt in O.P.Gauba's "Political Theory" and also through some online reading.
For Indian Political Thought , V.R.Mehta's book is a good source to study even if the language is not easy to master. Ambedkar and Syed Ahmed Khan are missing in this book which can be covered in IGNOU PDFs.I read the original texts of "Annihilation of caste" and "Hind Swaraj".
Part II
Indian Government and Politics:
I considered this entire section as an organic whole and the basic texts for it are B.L.Fadia, Laxmikanth, Ramachandra Guha and Bipan Chandra. But ultimately,this is a current affairs oriented section and we win or lose within the pages of a good newspaper.
Answers in these sections must have contemporary examples and can quote good authors. For example, for a question on "Marginalisation of Left Ideology in India" in 2014's paper, I quoted Ramachandra Guha's points from a piece for Caravan Magazine in June,2011. So, every weekend, few hours can be spent to browse websites of Indian Express, Outlook and India Today etc. There is a tendency to see Times of India as a frivolous page- 3 paper but it features columns of great writers like Sunil Khilnani and Gurcharan Das on a regular basis.
I would suggest columns of Ashutosh Varshney,Ramachandra Guha and Pratap Bhanu Mehta as mandatory reading for this section.
Paper II
Part I
Comparative Political Analysis and International Politics:
This can be divided into two sections : Comparative Politics and International Relations.
Comparative Politics was the only portion in PSIR's syllabus which never kindled my interest enough to do extensive reading. All I read for this section were IGNOU PDFs.
For International Relations,a wonderful introductory text is Globalisation of World Politics. This book is an absolute delight with great illustrations,brilliant design and most importantly,quality content. Any gaps in this book can be filled by selective reading of V.K.Malhotra's "International Relations".
Again,answers for this section can be written with references to recent examples. For example,an answer on National Security can mention Syrian crisis as an example.BBC website provides great summaries of all current international crises (Sample: See this)."Frontline" is a good Indian magazine to cover international events if one discounts it's blinkered worldview.
Part II
For Indian foreign Policy, a topnotch introductory text is David Malone's book. Gaps in this book can be filled by reading Shashi Tharoor OR Rajiv Sikri selectively.
But as anyone who saw/wrote 2014's paper would know, even without reading any book, this section can be mastered if we follow The Hindu and good columnists regularly. Some expert foreign policy commentators include : C.Rajamohan, Brahma Challaney ,Suhasini Haidar and Srinath Raghavan. (For a question on India-Russia relations, I almost reproduced Srinath Raghavan's viewpoints written in the pages of The Hindu five days before the exam.) I never read a single issue of World Focus (even though I bought so many issues only for them to rest in the attic) and relied more on these commentators I have mentioned.
Thus, PSIR can be mastered by a diverse reading habit along with very good writing. Why I insist on Andrew Heywood first (and not Gauba) and Srinath Raghavan (and not World Focus) is because when we read such lucidly written prose regularly, our writing will also gain finesse with time. So,our answers for PSIR should
i) introduce the statement in the question , analyse the viewpoints associated with it and conclude it . It is important to ensure our answers have a closure to it. We must not write like students appearing for B.A Pol. Sci exam.Rather,we must write like a bureaucrat submitting a report to a higher official.
ii) Our answers should have contemporary examples and touches.For example,a question on women panchayats should mention examples of successful and popular woman sarpanches.
iii) We can quote authors and columnists in answers. It adds to the intellectual heft of our viewpoints.
iv) Above all, reading more means writing better.
The above is not exactly a strategy but a recounting of what I did to score 138+140 in PSIR this year. All the best to all aspirants who are taking up this wonderful optional wherein we are mesmerised by Gandhi's idealism, stunned by Ambedkar's radicalism,transfixed by Aristotle's pragmatism,intrigued by Marx's,er,Marxism and exasperated by Modi's foreign policy tourism. ("Oh ,which country ? Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz wat ? Ok google "India- Kazakhstan relations"?)
Important Note : If you feel that the books mentioned fall short in a particular topic/dimension, do supplement it with IGNOU materials.
I'm not an aspirant of civil services but its really great to see that you maintain a journal to share knowledge with other aspirants. Excellent work Umesh.
ReplyDeleteThank you sir.
ReplyDeleteHai sir this is shourya. Thnks for your guidance. ....
ReplyDeleteThank you Umesh for your guidance .. I wish a very all the best for your career.. Am looking for further guidance in future.. From, Shivaraj......
ReplyDeletegreat job sir..looking forward to hear more from you regarding complete strategy for upsc preprations !!!!anticipating a post on how to prepare for civil services
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! I've been looking for books of this nature for a way too long. I'm just glad that I found yours. Looking forward for your next post. Thanks :)
ReplyDeleteonline yoga books in hindi
Online India tour-If traveling is the hobby along with you wish to stop by famous locations subsequently Indian journey stands out as the most suitable option for you personally. Indian is actually well-known around the world due to the famous locations, varied different languages along with beliefs, multi-colored nationalities and many other. The entire associated with Indian is actually broken down into four significant places my spouse and i. age. To the north, South, Eastern along with Western side. Every single part of Indian wil attract along with brimming with wonderful actions. This mantra intended for Indian native tourist is actually Athithi Devo Bhava.
ReplyDeleteVery well describe this blog. It provide well information.Please see also my site.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.tomarholidays.com/
Very well describe this blog. It provide well information.Please see also my site.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.tomarholidays.com/
ReplyDeleteThese are truly amongst the wonderful informative blogs.Thanks for sharing such informative blog article with us.
Kokoda Tours | Kokoda Track Tours
thanku sir..this is so helpful....
ReplyDeleteBest ias coaching in bangalore
ReplyDelete.www.globalias.in
It's a vast subject. Always really hard to cover.
ReplyDeletecheap the lumineers tickets
discount the lumineers tickets
I dont like PolSci, gives me headaches.
ReplyDeletesecure airport parking Manchester
Manchester parking deals
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteYes, political science really popular in India if you're planning to pursue a government or teaching job. Almost all entrance exams have political science as important component. If anyone planning to take MA Political Science at one of India's top universities then we could help. We provide quality MA Political Science Entrance exam coaching in Delhi. You can get more information here: https://learningskillsindia.com/batch/ma-political-science-entrance-coaching
ReplyDeleteHello sir can you please share your notes/mock test copies of PSIR? Would be of immense help
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing this information with us, this is a really great post, i glad to read this infor, now i am going to bookmark your post. college educational tour best tour package for college trip/
ReplyDeleteThe way you have presented the post with all the examples is also very impressive.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing!!
Amazing site!!.. i can't belive this. what an Wonderful photography.
the wedding photographers are doing a fabulous job. very stunning looking for that photo's.
Wedding venues in chennai
I would assume that we use more than the eyes to gauge a person's feelings. Mouth. Body language. Even voice. You could at least have given us a face in this test.
ReplyDeleteJava training in Chennai
Java training in Bangalore
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteReally very happy to say, your post is very interesting to read. I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job. Keep it up…
ReplyDeleteLooking for Software Training in Bangalore , learn from Softgen Infotech Software Courses on online training and classroom training. Join today!
a really nice blog!!
ReplyDeleteRegular Maths Optional Coaching Classes
Weekend Maths Optional Coaching Classes
Online Mathematics Optional Institute
Pen Drive Maths Optional Course
Wonderful blog & good post.Its really helpful for me, waiting for a more new post. Keep Blog.
ReplyDeletePython Training in Chennai
Python Training in Bangalore
Python Training in Hyderabad
Python Training in Coimbatore
Python Training
python online training
python flask training
python flask online training
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteLooking for convenient Manchester Airport Parking Deals? Look no further than Ezybook! Park your car hassle-free and jet off to your destination from the UK with ease.
ReplyDelete